Skip to content Accessibility info

Advanced Insurance Solutions Blog

All You Ever Wanted to Know About Insurance

Renting a Car for Thanksgiving? What Your Auto Insurance Covers (and What It Doesn't)

By Doug Erwin, Founder and Director of Personal Lines, Advanced Insurance Solutions · Updated November 9, 2026

Quick tip from Doug: Before you leave for Thanksgiving, pull up your auto policy and check one thing: do you carry comprehensive and collision on your own car? If you do, that coverage (and your deductibles) usually carries over to a rental car you're using for personal travel. If you've dropped them on an older car, the rental company's damage waiver deserves a much closer look. A quick call to us or your insurance company before your trip beats guessing at the counter.

You've finally made it to the front of the rental car line. The kids are tired, your flight was late, and the agent slides a form across the counter: "Would you like to add our protection package today?" You have about four seconds to decide.

You're not alone in that moment. AAA projected that 81.8 million Americans would travel at least 50 miles over Thanksgiving last year, most of them by car, and plenty of those trips start or end at a rental counter at Harrisburg International, BWI or the airport closest to Grandma's house.

From our offices in Hershey and York, we help drivers in Dauphin, Lebanon, Cumberland, Lancaster, York and Adams Counties, plus Harford, Baltimore and Carroll Counties in northern Maryland, make sense of exactly this question. Here's what to know before you go.

Does my car insurance cover a rental car?

Often, yes, at least for personal trips. According to the Insurance Information Institute (Triple-I), in most cases the auto insurance and deductibles you have on your own car apply when you rent a car for recreation.

That means:

Your liability coverage usually follows you, which helps if you injure someone or damage their property while driving the rental.

Your collision and comprehensive coverage usually extends to damage to the rental car itself, minus your deductible.

If you only carry liability on your own car, there's often no coverage for damage to the rental. Triple-I warns that if you dropped collision or comprehensive, you may not be covered if the rental is stolen or damaged.

Policies differ, especially on rentals outside the U.S. and Canada, longer-term rentals and moving trucks, so check yours before you travel.

Should I buy the damage waiver at the counter?

The collision damage waiver (CDW) or loss damage waiver (LDW) is the big-ticket item on that rental form. Triple-I points out that a waiver isn't technically an insurance product. It's the rental company agreeing not to hold you responsible for damage or theft. It may also cover things your personal policy might not, such as loss-of-use charges, towing and administrative fees.

It can make sense to consider the waiver if:

You don't carry collision or comprehensive on your own car.

Your deductible is high and you'd rather not risk paying it on a rental.

You're renting for business, where your personal policy may not apply.

Read the fine print, though. Triple-I notes waivers can be voided by things like speeding, driving on unpaved roads or driving while intoxicated.

Does my credit card cover rental cars?

Many cards offer some rental car protection, but it varies a lot. Triple-I notes that credit card benefits are usually secondary, meaning they kick in after your personal auto policy, and sometimes they only cover your deductible. Benefits depend on the card issuer and card level, and you typically have to decline the rental company's waiver and pay for the rental with that card.

Our advice: call the number on the back of your card and ask for the coverage details in writing before your trip. If you carry more than one card, compare them.

What about liability in a rental?

Rental companies are required to provide the state minimum liability coverage, and Triple-I notes that often isn't enough protection. If you have your own auto policy, your liability limits usually apply. If you don't own a car but rent often, a non-owner auto policy can give you liability coverage that follows you. A personal umbrella policy may also add a layer on top.

What about medical bills and stuff stolen from the car?

The rental counter may also offer personal accident insurance and personal effects coverage. Whether you need them depends on what you already have. Pennsylvania drivers carry first-party medical benefits on their auto policy, and your health insurance may also respond. Belongings stolen from a rental are often covered by your homeowners or renters policy, subject to your deductible.

What if I'm using a car-sharing or peer-to-peer service?

Car-sharing programs and peer-to-peer apps work differently from traditional rental companies. Triple-I notes that car-sharing fees generally include some insurance, but you may be billed a set amount after a collision or theft unless you buy a waiver, and peer-to-peer services may offer a range of options. Check the app's coverage details before you book, and ask us whether your personal policy applies.

What if my own car is in the shop?

That's a different coverage: rental reimbursement. It's an optional add-on that helps pay for a rental while your car is being repaired after a covered claim. It's usually inexpensive, and it's especially handy in deer season, when body shops in Central PA stay busy.

A quick pre-trip checklist

Check your declarations page for comprehensive, collision and rental reimbursement.

Call your card issuer and ask whether its rental coverage is primary or secondary.

Take photos or a short video of the rental car, inside and out, before you leave the lot.

Keep the rental agreement and the company's roadside number handy.

Know who's driving. Additional drivers usually need to be listed on the rental agreement.

Frequently asked questions

Does my Pennsylvania auto policy cover a rental car in Maryland or another state?

Typically, a personal auto policy applies throughout the U.S. and Canada, so a rental in Maryland, Virginia or Florida is usually treated like a rental at home. Check your policy for its coverage territory.

Do I have to pay my deductible if I damage a rental car?

If you're relying on your own collision coverage, usually yes. Some credit card benefits may help with the deductible, and the rental company's waiver may eliminate it.

Will a claim on a rental car affect my insurance rates?

It can. A rental car claim under your policy is generally treated like a claim on your own car. Rating rules vary by insurance company.

Does my auto insurance cover a rental for a business trip?

Not always. Triple-I notes that personal coverage applies to rentals for recreation. If you're traveling for work, ask your employer what coverage it provides.

Is rental car coverage different for young drivers?

Rental companies often have age rules and extra fees for drivers under 25, and Triple-I notes car-sharing coverage for drivers under 21 is often limited to the state minimum. Check before your college student books a car.

Hit the road with confidence

A five-minute review before Thanksgiving can tell you whether you need anything at the rental counter. Because we work with more than 20 insurance companies, we can also compare your current coverage against other options. Request an auto quote or call us at 717-533-0252 (Hershey) or 717-845-1500 (York). You're always welcome to stop by our Hershey office on West Chocolate Avenue or our York office on South Queen Street.

Sources: Triple-I: Rental car insurance · Triple-I: Does auto insurance cover a rental replacement car after an accident? · AAA Central Penn: Thanksgiving travel forecast

Coverage, deductibles and rental rules vary by insurance company, policy, card issuer and rental company. This article is general information, not a coverage guarantee. Talk with a licensed agent about your specific policy.